There are some treads in THT regarding problems with B175 and the 1234xsv.
Reason for the problems are not really clear to me, some had the transducer tested and found good but still acting up,
others had the transducer replaced under warranty and solved the problem, but it seems that this problems are happening only connected to a 1234xsv. Should you have a 1234XSV I would be careful and investigate well before installing this transducer.
However, the B164 / 175 shape works very well if is installed on the correct location, i have a non-chirp B164 on my RIB and he read up to 32 knots on shallower depths and down to about 1000 ft going slower.
However, if it would be my boat I would pull both old transducers just to free the space, for safety reasons and have less drag,
but that would lead to close correctly the hole from the not used one.
Another option would be to install two thru hulls:
a) not necessary to glass close one of both holes
b) install two same side-scan transducers for side-scan or two different transducers for different purposes
I personally would pull the trigger and install two, either side-scan or two totally different ones if that is needed.
BTW:
I noticed the two "grooves" in the hull on a 2001 306 Bimini and guessed that they are the transducer mounting locations,
is that correct?
Has someone considered to fill and glass even the two transducer mount locations to get a flat hull surface there?
If a B175 transducer is installed on a different location the two unused grooves would be obsolete and a flat hull there may reduce drag?
Chris