agm battery

dogdoc

GreatGrady Captain
Joined
Apr 23, 2019
Messages
443
Reaction score
85
Points
28
Age
72
Model
Marlin
Recently had to replace battery on daughter inlaws jeep Wrangler unlimited. Specs call for agm battery. I think they are going to sell soon, I am putting in flooded and saving a few bucks. Guy at Autozone is not happy says I need agm but sells me flooded. Just before I put it in, I do a quick Google and sure enough the list of problems with flooded cause me to go back to auto zone and pay the extra for agm. The guys at Autozone are so happy I came back and proceed to tell me I would not have been happy. So now I think that pretty soon I was going to rebattery my boat and use agm batteries. I have df250 mechanical Suzuki's. Low and behold Suzuki does not recommend agm and mandates flooded. What do I not know about agm vs flooded. Honestly I would have thought interchangeable.
 
Recently had to replace battery on daughter inlaws jeep Wrangler unlimited. Specs call for agm battery. I think they are going to sell soon, I am putting in flooded and saving a few bucks. Guy at Autozone is not happy says I need agm but sells me flooded. Just before I put it in, I do a quick Google and sure enough the list of problems with flooded cause me to go back to auto zone and pay the extra for agm. The guys at Autozone are so happy I came back and proceed to tell me I would not have been happy. So now I think that pretty soon I was going to rebattery my boat and use agm batteries. I have df250 mechanical Suzuki's. Low and behold Suzuki does not recommend agm and mandates flooded. What do I not know about agm vs flooded. Honestly I would have thought interchangeable.
Don't overthink it. Use flooded lead acid on your boat. they will last 5 years. Everything will work.
 
I
Recently had to replace battery on daughter inlaws jeep Wrangler unlimited. Specs call for agm battery. I think they are going to sell soon, I am putting in flooded and saving a few bucks. Guy at Autozone is not happy says I need agm but sells me flooded. Just before I put it in, I do a quick Google and sure enough the list of problems with flooded cause me to go back to auto zone and pay the extra for agm. The guys at Autozone are so happy I came back and proceed to tell me I would not have been happy. So now I think that pretty soon I was going to rebattery my boat and use agm batteries. I have df250 mechanical Suzuki's. Low and behold Suzuki does not recommend agm and mandates flooded. What do I not know about agm vs flooded. Honestly I would have thought interchangeable.
I'm going to give you my opinion of you statement "What do I not know about agm vs flooded. Honestly I would have thought interchangeable"

Flooded , maintenance free, AGM and Gel are all lead acid batteries and are for the most part interchangeable. The biggest difference between all is material used to make them, how they are vented , charge profiles and how many charge cycles they can tolerate before they fail. I am keeping this basic. IMO the flooded lead acid battery is the most basic and forgiving battery made and has been for most of us a go to for many years. The flooded LA battery is usually the cheapest, for years it has been considered a 3 year battery. If it is not maintained and charged/discharged within its designed specification it will not last as long and if it is maintained, charged and discharged within it's design parameters it may last longer than 3 years.

AGM batteries have a more complex charge profile. They can charge and discharge quickly without damage. AGM does not like to be charged at voltages above 14.6V. AMG batteries also should be charged in a three step charging method. This is why Suzuki is saying don't use AGM. Suzuki DF250 has a basic charge coil, rectifier/regulator with a regulated voltage of 14.2 to 15.2 volts. AGM do not like charge voltages above 14.6V. If a AGM is over charged it is not going to destroy it but it could decrease the longevity. AGM are pricey so why buy one and get less longevity? Save youR money purchase a good flooded battery and let the simple charging system charge the battery.

The Jeep like many newer vehicles has a start stop system plus a lot more electrical systems that require more AH to operate. The AGM start battery have a lot of CCA and the ability to charge and discharge quicker than a flooded battery. The AGM if alternator charged should be charged with a smart alternator to maintain its designed longevity. For this reason the AGM in newer vehicles is the recommended replacement. The AGM is rated for 3X charging cycles when compared to a flooded LA battery. With all the start stops a new vehicle engine makes this will make a big difference in longevity.

IMO, for basic cruising with an outboards equipped with a basic charging system the engine start battery should be a flooded LA quality battery. I you want to have a house battery with higher AH and quicker charge characteristics install an AGM, GEL or better lithium. Add a DC to DC charger to the 12V system so it can be charged using a proper charge profile for that battery.

EXAMPLE= You have a DF 250 Suzuki with a 54 AMP charging capacity. It takes about 10 amps of 12v to run the engine systems. This gives the charging output of 40a to 44a. This is the available charge capacity to charge the start battery. After the start battery is fully charged the voltage regulator dumps the charge. If a DC to DC charger is wired to the start battery then to a AGM OR LITHIUM house battery. The DC to DC charger can be programed to charge the house battery to the correct charge profile and give you the designed longevity and a better use of your house bank.

If you want to keep it simple purchase a goo flooded LA battery and leave it at that.
Brian
 
thanks Brian great info and analysis. I did not mean to imply interchangeable with identical. I was aware of subtle differences but had no idea they could be so consequential. I do use flooded everywhere boats , tractors, solar arrays, and with good maintenance get way more than 3 years. Why did I want agm, it is a royal pia to check water levels on the Grady. Guess I will just have to limber up and do it
 
I remember having this conversation on the forum here, I believe it was earlier this year on flooded vs AGM batteries. One member mentioned using the Duracell brand of batteries, particularly of the AGM variety. He sent a link to the Sam's Club website for the particular batteries that he was recommending, which had less than a 4 out of 5 star rating and it seemed like the majority of the negative reviews were pretty much all for the same thing... something to the effect of "the batteries only lasted a year and a half or less before they died on me." For me personally, I'm about longevity and as little maintenance on things like batteries as possible, etc. The concept of spending the same, if not even more money, on a product that isn't as dependable or doesn't last as long as the other, is frankly quite absurd to me.

I bought my boat in October of 2021 and replaced the batteries on it in the fall/winter of 2023 when I took her out of the water for the season, as the current batteries wouldn't start up the boat. I didn't know the age of the current batteries at the time as I bought the boat that way, and there wasn't a time date/stamp/sticker/tag on them. But I was a bit curious on the matter, so I called up my local Grady White dealership here in Edmonds to see what they recommended. They said "replace the batteries with the exact same ones that you've already got. Same number of batteries, same size Group number and same style/material used." I told them that I had two starting Group 24 flooded batteries, then specifically asked if I should spend the extra money and go with AGM batteries to see if they were more beneficial or longer lasting. Of which the tech said that they'd been having a lot of problems with the AGM batteries that they'd been putting on their boats with vibration issues, a lack of longevity and so forth. Ultimately at the end of the day, he recommended just using the flooded batteries as that is what's been around for more than half a century now, that's what they still use/recommend and have found is the longest lasting for them. Right, wrong or indifferent... that's just what I've seen online and have been told from my local Grady White dealership. Good luck.
 
Last edited: