Can I use a F350hp on my Islander ?

Cadeco

Well-Known Member
Joined
Dec 16, 2021
Messages
87
Reaction score
9
Points
8
Location
Palm Beach
Model
Islander
My 1998 Islander says it can go 400 hp., mine has (now) an Yamaha F250, I feel it is underpowered, but had the idea of getting twin HPDIs or E-tecs (200 hp each) due to weight concerns. The other day a friend asked me:" Why not use an 350hp instead of 2 200's? I would be missing only 50hp and the cost to install the twins when there is only one would disappear. What do you guys think? An F350 would weight also less than twin 200s. What should I do?
Thanks to all answers!!!
 
Are you looking at a new 350 or an older model year? I ask because I would be very leery about earlier model year 350s. Many had some serious issues.
I would prefer twin engines for better handling. That said, it seems to me that you are on a budget with your engine options. 350s are less expensive because many don't want the possible headaches.
E-tecs are lower priced because Evinrude shut down and getting parts and service can be challenging.
HDPI are decent engines but you have to figure in the oil tanks, plumbing and wiring harnesses.
In general, going to twins from a single Yamaha will require new controls steering gear, gauges, harnesses , battery wiring etc.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cadeco
If your boat is currently set up for a single main motor, I think repowering with a single would be the most cost effective way of going about doing it. If money isn't an issue then you could always look at twins, but I think the biggest consideration would be your particular boating/fishing needs. If you constantly go out 40-50+ miles each way offshore and want the extra motor for safety/redundancy... then it's definitely a consideration. If looking at it just to have it, probably not needed imo. If you're looking at a new or newer F350 then they I've heard are quite good, but some of the late 2000's/early 2010's vintages of F350's I've heard can have issues. I believe most of which are the flywheels that would need to be replaced, and I guess some of them were quite heavy, though probably not as heavy as twin outboards. I'd consider looking at Suzuki as well as Mercury for whatever you end up deciding on, new vs used, in that Mercury generally has the lightest outboard options out there, especially if you did go with twins. Or if you wanted to go new, they as well as Suzuki both, make a 350, and I believe Mercury even makes a single 400. A bit more information is needed here in regard to if you're wanting new vs used, your budget, if you don't mind sticking with a single main motor, etc, but yes to answer your question... there's no reason why you couldn't go with a single main F350 on your boat, especially if it's already setup for a single main motor.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Cadeco
Thanks guys: Yes money is short. The F350 I'm looking for is a 2008/9 model. I would prefer twins, but the labor to install would be costly, I know many concerns w/ E-tecs due to no more available, but in my opinion, they are very good motors and would work fine. I had a chance to get twin 150s but the difference to my 250 would not worth the hassle. 175hp could work but is tough to find a good used pair.
 
there seem to be lots of gen 2 etecs around with low hours... usually cheap. gear cases and steering seem to be problematic but if you can get some spares they would be a good match for your hull. I think a lot of people are panicking and dumping otherwise good motors.

twin f200's were ample power on my 2004 270.