Patsy Mac, I have a 96 268 Islander with a 2019 Suzuki 300 AP. The new Suzuki props were limited to a minimum pitch of 17". I used to have a single Yammi 250 and ran a 15 x 15 prop. My Islander is heavy with hardtop, enclosure, lots of gear, at 5100 rpm she would run about 31 mph. The new 300 with the 16 dia x 17pitch prop gave a horrible holeshot, but the top end was something I never experienced with my Yamaha. The Suzuki would only spin up to about 4750 rpm but she was going about 39 mph. The new Suzuki has a wot of 6200 rpm so the 17p was too much prop. After several trips to the prop shop we ended up with a 14 1/2 pitch full cupped 16" dia wheel. My wot speed is around 34 at 6000, at 4600 about 24mph and depending on sea conditions 1.9 to 2.4 mpg. I would think that 4900 rpm is too low for your F250 and that 19p is way too much pitch. You have to be able to spin up close to your wot range or you are working your engine way too hard drastically shortening its life.