I had similar issues. I installed Armstrong compression deck plate. Had to cut bigger hole in bracket to fit deck plate. You only have one chance so go slow and measure twice. Been in the water for a month and it's doing great. I wanted easily remove able plate so I could remove water from inside bracket if it started to fill up again. I keep the boat in the water and I don't have easy access to my trailer.
Save More on Your Armstrong Watertight Compression Deck Plates at Fisheries Supply. Excellent Customer Service, Ready to Ship. Marine Supplies Since 1928!
www.fisheriessupply.com